Ubuntu is not quite ready for non-geek users.
After years of cursing you know who I finally took the plunge. I decided to switch to Ubuntu cold turkey. I love it – am glad I did it – and do not regret. I just wish it were finally ready for prime time – it isn’t. IF you personally know a computer geek who will assist you or are a do-it-yourself type with the time to figure it all out I encourage you to go for it now.
If that does not describe you hang on for a bit. I will be posting here about learning Ubuntu and recording the how-to information I have to research. I will also do my best to help the wonderful folks donating their time and expertise to the Ubuntu project so we can get it to the point that it IS ready for anyone currently using Microsoft Windows, Vista, Apple or Mac.
Installing Ubuntu was easy. Using it is easy to figure out – until you run into something that is not already set up. And then the non-geek user is stuck. IMHO (Internet geek-speak for in my humble opinion), that is the reason Ubuntu is not ready for the regular user.
You have to know or figure out how to do things that are done for you in Windows or Mac. For example:
- PDF Files: You have to select a PDF viewer. I chose one of two open source offerings. It took three tries to get it to install.
- VIDEO: Instead of the usual video view window I have a multi-tone gray box with a gray arrow inside a circle. When I click the arrow to start play I had to install a player. That process hung Firefox. I tried restarting Firefox – no help. I had to reboot Ubuntu. Repeated tries end in that same “search for codec” message or acting like the video is playing but only a black box in the viewer.
- INSTALLING SOFTWARE: Will it work? How do I install it? Firefox automatically downloaded my favorite keyword research program. It is a .exe file but Firefox doesn’t know what to do with it and neither do I. I just found How to Install ANYTHING in Ubuntu so off I go to figure it out.
- ADDING FEATURES: Ubuntu comes with all kinds of neat “stuff” you can add – IF you can figure out how. You go to System, Administration, Synaptic Package Manager and check what you want to add. That is the easy part. The challenge is figuring out which package you want because the descriptions are unclear to mere mortals. Then if you figure out what to add many of them require manual (non-GUI) set-up. For example, I loaded kweather which “displays your area’s current weather. Information shown includes the temperature, wind speed, air pressure and more. By pressing a button a full weather report can be obtained.” Since I have no idea how to change the location setting it sits in my toolbar with — displayed. When I point at the dashes it says updating. Hmmm….maybe I’ll get it figured out later.
About installing programs Jonathan Schlaffer of Tech.Blorge wrote, “I know plenty of people that think doing so is hard in Windows and for them it would be impossible in Linux.” He’s right. In his excellent post he asks “why can’t I just install an executable or msi file and be done with it? Linux doesn’t work that way which is why it will never be ready for Joe Schmo user…”.
[Corrected Nov. 5, 2008] In his Sep. 14, 2007 post titled Ubuntu Not Ready for Prime Time, Says Walt Mossberg, Jack Schofield, Computer Editor for The Guardian.co.uk, quoted Wall Street Journal’s technology columnist Walt Mossberg. Walt sums up his opinion of Ubuntu this way:
“My verdict: Even in the relatively slick Ubuntu variation, Linux is still too rough around the edges for the vast majority of computer users. While Ubuntu looks a lot like Windows or Mac OS X, it is full of little complications and hassles that will quickly frustrate most people who just want to use their computers, not maintain or tweak them.”
I believe it CAN be made as easy to use as Windows or Mac as soon as the brilliant people who design it accept that it must be really, really GUI simple. Hardy Heron is MUCH easier to use than Feisty Fawn was. The other thing Ubuntu needs is documentation written for non-technical users. I’ll be happy to contribute them – as soon as I can figure it out myself.
If, like me, you’re just NOT going to use Vista and you’re willing to be a leader, read Making the Switch to Ubuntu 8.04 Hardy Heron. As soon as I get up to speed I’ll be adding lots of how-to posts and willing to help non-technical users get it working for them.
Please share your insights, comments, and experiences in the comments. Feel free to drop links to related information you find helpful. Periodically I will move those links up into the body of the most appropriate post here for fast and easy reference.
- Are you using Ubuntu? Tell us about it.
- Is there something you just can’t get it to do? Let us know and we’ll research and post the answer.
NOTES:
* I am using Ubuntu 8.04 The Hardy Heron released April 2008. It came preloaded with Firefox version 3.0.1. I welcome comments from Ubuntu developers and users and am interested in offering feedback and writing documentation for non-geeks.
** I know that true geeks do not understand why we non-geeks struggle with all this. Imagine that you don’t know anything about computers, hardware, programming, Linux terminology and jargon – not even what a command line is or how to get to one – nothing at all. Then try having to read the [completely incomprehensible to us] help files and look up every acronym and figure out every instruction.
UBUNTU HOW-TO:
- Get Organized Using Tomboy Notes
- Using the Wine Windows Emulator to Run Windows Programs on Ubuntu
- Taking a Screen Capture in Ubuntu Using Gimp and Inserting It Into a Blog Post
OFFICIAL UBUNTU REFERENCE RESOURCES:
- Documentation for Ubuntu 8.04 LTS (Official Help)
- Adding and Removing Software
- Add/Remove Applications (Similar to Windows Add/Remove)
- Switching From Windows
- Ubuntu Community Provided Documentation
Special thanks to Boo Radley for providing the information that led to the above Official Ubuntu Help links.
BLOGGERS WRITING ABOUT THEIR EXPERIENCES LEARNING TO USE UBUNTU:
- The Linux Terminal for Beginners from Dave’s Tech Blog – “A very long time ago, computers didn’t have mice, icons or fancy graphics.” Great resource here – go directly to his Ubuntu posts.
- Still Stupid: STumbling in Linux Land – Unlucky Pablo: The tribulations and happy discoveries of a Linux Newbie
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES ABOUT UBUNTU:
- Has Ubuntu Lost Its Relevance? (Aug 27, 2008)
- Ubuntu Attracts Lion’s Share at LinuxWorld (Aug 10, 2008)
- I Love Wine Under Ubuntu (Jul 30, 2008) [NOTE: Wine allows Windows programs to run on Ubuntu]
- Six Annoyances in Hardy Heron by Matt Cutts (May 20, 2008)
- Ubuntu Hardy Heron Distro Review (May 15, 2008)
- Ubuntu 8.04 Not Quite There Yet (May 9, 2008)
- What to Say About Hardy Heron (Apr 28, 2008)
- Make the Switch to Ubuntu 8.04 Hardy Heron (Apr 27, 2008)
- FOSSWire Hardy Heron Review (Apr 24, 2008)
- Jack Schofield finds Ubuntu “unusably user hostile” (Sep 14, 2007)
- Linux’s New System is Now Easier to Use, But Not For Everyone (Sep 13, 2007)
- Ubuntu Not Ready for Average Users (Sep 12, 2007)
- Ubuntu is Not Ready for Prime Time (Aug 10, 2007)
- Switching to Linux? Look Before You Leap (Jul 9, 2007)
- Confessions of a Linux Fan; Ten Things You Might Want to Know Before Switching Over to Linux (Jul 8, 2007)
- Ubuntu is Not Ready for Most, Even From Dell (May 6, 2007)
ONLINE REFERENCE SOURCES:
- Full Circle – Free online magazine devoted to Ubuntu
- Excellent Ubuntu Reference – direct links to frequently used information including free formats for video and music
HOW TO GET UBUNTU THE MOST PAINLESS WAY:
Buying a PC with Ubuntu already installed on it from someone who really knows Ubuntu is the most logical, pain-free way to get it. The most promising offerings I’ve found so far come from system76. Their systems are preloaded with the software programs you’re most likely to need, saving you the challenges of figuring out which to use and how to install them. There are other companies that offer preloaded Ubuntu hardware internationally.
DISCLAIMER: We are not being compensated in any way by system76 – they don’t even know we exist – yet. We do intend to contact them and will provide additional information in the near future.
Gail Gardner
Latest posts by Gail Gardner (see all)
- 50 Places to Repurpose Web Conferences as Video Content - January 22, 2020
- How to Attract Organic Links and Mentions with Content - December 18, 2019
- How to Stop Doing Outreach Wrong! What Sites Really Want - November 29, 2019
Ubuntu is just amazing, because of ease it provides to its users is very good, and its UI is also very Clean and friendly.
Would definitely prefer Ubuntu any times any day,
Great Post.
That’s what I want to talk about. It comes with so many benefits. In compare to windows Ubantu is not crash so we used it long time.
The one thing g I’ve noticed here and would like to mention as an IT person is that I have noticed that everything is made for us to be more and more simple, not just Windows or Mac. IMHO that is where the problem lay. We are moving further and further down the “technological rabbit hole” and need to be familiar with more than click, click, click. That was my personal reason for diving into Linux. I would write something a bit more detailed but I’m on the commute home lol. 🙂
Good to know. We recently switched to a mobile responsive theme so the site would display better on mobile devices. If you happened to see it before or have comments on how it displays now we’d love to hear.
We’re in 2011 now and I still use Microsoft software. I can switch to Ubuntu, but not too many software programs compatible with linux.
Hi Anna,
Most of the commonly used Microsoft programs have Open Source versions including Microsoft Office alternatives. You can get information and download them them free at that link.
The only applications I really want that don’t work on Linux are the best contact manager program I’ve ever used Time & Chaos, a specialized pedigree program for horses, and Go to Webinar which STILL does not support Linux.
Gail Gardner would love you to read ..Why Small Business and Bloggers Can NOT Ignore Economic Decline and Occupy Wall Street
It’s true, Ubuntu isn’t for the “Regular Joe,” which is probably why it doesn’t come pre-installed for the vast majority of standard computers. It’s kind of the level above, the program that is it’s own “super-geek.” Though, most people who work in the digital world, be it Internet, Gaming, Online-Marketing will tell you that they prefer it over Windows. Though, if it’s so much better- why don’t you think they come out with a more general version?
@ Walt: My thanks for pointing out this confusion and my sincere apology. I have corrected the post to clarify this is Walt’s opinion rather than yours. No guarantees that there are no copies of the original archived though.
I never worry about what people say because, as you note, if they can’t find anything truthful to write they’ll just make things up anyway. As we know, the only way to avoid criticism is “to do nothing, be nothing, and say nothing”.
> Jack Schofield finds Ubuntu “unusably user hostile” (Sep 14, 2007)
Can I just point out that I found no such thing?
The post this links to is headlined:
Ubuntu not ready for prime time, says Walt Mossberg
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/blog/2007/sep/14/ubuntunotreadyforprimetim
I am reporting Walt’s opinion. You refer to exactly the same story in your own excellent post.
Only idiot fanboys confuse reporting something with believing or saying something, and I’d rather you didn’t give the idiot fanboys any ammunition. They make up more than enough lies about me as it is 😉
No problem. I’m curious as to how you ended up with two PDF readers. For as long as I’ve been using it, Ubuntu has contained only eVince. (under “Graphics” even though it should really be under office)…
I don’t remember if it’s this was by default, but the Add/Remove program should be in the *root* of one of the menus to make it more readily accessible… I have the alternate menu style that’s more like a “start button” under Windows.
The sad truth with computers (and I’m not saying this is the case with you) is that the majority of people *just barely* know how to use them. That is, they can click the start button find their program and use maybe about 10% of its features. Regardless of the operating system, if something isn’t setup by default most people are going to have difficulty setting it up and aren’t resourceful enough to check the help file or search the web.
I myself had to install a program on a Mac and was a bit flummoxed by the process… Something about a .dmg file and it was installed, but not really installed (mounted?), etc… Compared to checking off a program in Add/Remove (once you know it’s there) installing (and keeping upgraded) software on other O/S’s is a nightmare. On Windows it seems every program has its own “update manager” that is constantly phoning home and annoying users with balloons and what-not.
People want computers to be like appliances, but regardless of the O/S they are not. Computers are complicated devices, and if you’re clueless on certain other O/S’s you’ll find yourself with a disk full o’viruses or not being able to get what you want done.
The irony is that Linux (esp. Ubuntu) is very good for the novice user who want to perform simple tasks accomplished with the included software, or for the expert that wants to do complicated things and knows how to get the job done. Where you often run into trouble at this stage is with the quasi-experienced user who wants to perform some intermediate activity and is well versed in Linux or does not know how to find out what they need to do…
Hello Boo and thank you so much for taking the time to comment. I actually DID have to choose a PDF viewer as there were TWO pre-installed.
I had no idea there WAS an Add/Remove Program feature. I just found it. (Applications, Add/Remove). I am VERY new to Ubuntu and obviously managed to miss the obvious – and it appears that others have too.
I have now located the information you mention and added a new section called Official Ubuntu Reference Sources with links to the specific help files you “found” for me – and also a note on how to access them from any Ubuntu installation.
No matter how well anything is documented Newbies will still have to go through a learning curve and nothing helps as much as one-on-one instant help. Thank you for helping me so that I can help many.
Couple points I’d like to make:
Ubuntu comes with a PDF viewer pre-installed… no selecting needed…
Installing Software/Adding Features…. You’re much better using the Add/Remove Program feature (vs. Synaptic) which features clear descriptions of programs which are not only categorizes programs, but also rates them based on popularity.
A quick search for “installing softwate” in Ubuntu Help would have told you this (no need to go looking off at other sites). But I suppose users don’t think to use the built-in help regardless of what O/S they use…
“In his excellent post he asks “why can’t I just install an executable or msi file and be done with it? Linux doesn’t work that way which is why it will never be ready for Joe Schmo user…”.”
— Ummm Ubuntu/Debian linux has these things call .deb’s which pretty much do what you’re asking… Although for the most part not necessary as most any software is already in the repos and available via Add/Remove… This is a little like chastising Windows for not running Mac .dmg install files…
Check out the built-in help in Ubuntu sometime (not the “man” pages). I think you’ll find it very easy to understand and written for non-geeks.