GrowMap Anti-Spambot Plugin

617 comments

Stop Spam Image

For support or questions please contact Gail at GrowMap not Andy!

We are absolutely thrilled and relieved that our spam problems are over. We went from 1000+ spam comments a day to not a single automated spam comment at all. Logging in to see only 12-50 real comments left by real people who have no problems commenting any more is a joy.

Download GrowMap Anti-Spambot Plugin (G.A.S.P.) now.

With the custom GrowMap anti-spambot plugin Andy Bailey from CommentLuv wrote based on an idea from Phil Hollows of FeedBlitz and improved by a suggestion from Dazzlin Donna Fontenot you can too!

IMPORTANT !!!

NEW: If you suddenly get an influx of spam and trackback spam while using
GASP and Simple Trackback Validation
check for errors in the STV plugin or
delete, re-upload & reintall it. Spammers have found a way to hack that plugin.

This plugin plus a trackback blocker and the blacklist function
built into WordPress provides a complete anti-spam solution.

GASP is built into CommentLuv Premium.

The plugin is already installed in all of our blogs plus all of Murray Newland‘s blogs, at Influence People and in dozens of our closest collaborators’ blogs too. The blogs range from WordPress 2.9.1 to 3.0.1 and we have run into no conflicts or problems installing it or running it in any blog so far.

If you are using our plugin please visit the GrowMap Anti-Spam WordPress plugin page and indicate that it works so that bloggers who do not know us will know to trust it. Thank you.

This plugin would not exist if it were not for the tenacity of the fine folks at Linda Christas College who kept explaining why how we are allowing our commentators to be treated was rude and especially bad for business blogs.

I am embarrassed to admit that even I did not clearly understand for too long, but once I did I found they were absolutely correct. We simply can not allow our readers and commentators to be sent to a blank white page, have their comments immediately deleted before we even see them, or to not receive a message that their comment is being moderated.

The plugin blocks BOTS not human spammers. If you have a problem with comments that look like comments but are actually trackback spam see Justin Germino’s post about the plugin we’re all using to block trackback spam.

Manually created spam can be blocked by WordPress by adding the url, email address or words to the blacklist function built into WordPress. Log into WordPress and go to Settings > Discussion > Comment Blacklist and type or paste what you want to blacklist into that box.

Comments captured by the blacklist go to the spam section of your comments.

NOTE: “When a comment contains any of these words in its content, name, URL, e-mail, or IP, it will be marked as spam. One word or IP per line. It will match inside words, so “press” will match “WordPress”.”

Be careful not to block comments containing words that have parts of other words within them and do check your spam folder and rescue good comments. If you realize you’re blocking a word you can edit the blacklist.

1) NOTE: Be sure to read the readme file about installing the plugin. You will NOT see the check box if you are logged in. Additional details:

The checkbox only appears for logged out users.
If you’re logged out, it only shows if you have javascript enabled.
If you are logged out and have javascript enabled and it is still not showing then you need to have the comment form action active in your comments.php theme file
` do_action(‘comment_form’,$post->ID); `

2) Why Use the GrowMap Anti-Spambot Plugin?

  1. No false positives – your favorite commentators and new readers WILL be able to easily comment in your blog.
  2. Blocks spam that Akismet was letting through. We are getting ZERO bot spam. Only those commenting manually who check the “I am not a spammer box” can leave comments.
  3. Easier for commentators than using a Captcha or math plugin – never a “wrong” answer that isn’t wrong or a problem with cookies!

3) Do other bloggers use and recommend G.A.S.P.?

  • See the GrowMap Anti-SpamBot Testimonials – collected from the comments left in the official WordPress plugin repository.
  • Reviews of GrowMap Anti-SpamBot Plugin on other blogs (There are so many that it will take time for me to compile them all. Coming as soon as time allows.)

4) What if my readers and commentators do not have JavaScript enabled?

  • While most Internet users today DO have Javascript enabled, there is a GASP PHP version created by Doug Neubauer that can be coded into your blog if you have technical skills.

5) What if I want to move the position of the Check Box??

  • The checkbox will appear wherever the do_action(‘comment_form’,$post->ID); command in their themes comments.php . It is that command that tells WordPress plugins that the comment form is being rendered to the page and any plugins that want to add something to the form should do it now. If they want to move it, they need to edit their comments.php file and move that command (it should not be outside the <form> </form> tags and needs to be enclosed in <?php ?> tags if it isn’t already part of some php block)

6) Why Not Just Use Akismet?

  1. Large numbers of bloggers and regular commentators who never spam have been flagged by Akismet as spammers.
  2. Any commentator who has been flagged as a spammer is treated rudely by your blog. They never see the message your comment is being moderated so they have no way of knowing what happened to their comment.
  3. If you have a particular box checked in the Akismet configuration, comments left for real people who have been flagged incorrectly as commentators in posts more than 30 days old are immediately deleted and they see a blank white page. See how to turn off Akismet Comment deletion.
  4. Read the many other posts and hundreds of comments related to problems with Akismet.

7) Why We Stopped Using Captchas and the Math Plugin:

  1. Even when your commentators enter the captcha or math solution correctly they are sometimes told they have entered it incorrectly.
  2. We had three complaints from regular commentators who are experienced bloggers within 48 hours of testing. If they don’t know that deleting cookies will probably resolve the problems of incorrect answers neither will your ordinary readers.
  3. They can be difficult for older people and those with poor vision to read.

8) Why We Don’t Recommend Using Bad Behavior:

We tested the Bad Behavior plugin and it behaved very badly, locking all three admins out of this blog. Even after using ftp to remove the plugin we were unable to log in. It took input from five top collaborators with very advanced WordPress skills to find and remove all the files necessary to recover from that test. Most bloggers do not know that many WP experts who have that kind of skills. Some have had to resort to reloading their blogs to recover.

Special thanks to Sammy Russo of  Search Friendly Web Design, Derek Semmler of  Team Thesis, Imran Yousaf of Blogging Junkie who loves optimizing blog load times, Donna Fontenot known for her eBusiness Coaching and Andrew Rondeau who writes about how to make a blog for their assistance at recovering from that test and also for testing this new plugin.

Thanks to all the bloggers who have commented on using G.A.S.P. and are promoting it in their own blogs.

9) G.A.S.P. VERSIONS:

There is a changelog section in the WordPress page for every plugin that indicates what changes with each version. The original version worked fine; however, there have been significant improvements since then:

  • 0.4 added the warning suggested by Dazzlin Donna Fontenot that pops up a message if you forget to check the box. That eliminated the problem of possibly losing your comment if you forget.
  • 1.01 resolved a problem that the plugin did not work with some custom Themes (identified by Dragonblogger).
  • Before 1.02 the plugin blocked trackbacks and pingbacks. Ileane noticed that and asked that they be unblocked.
  • Some bloggers including Dragonblogger are plagued by spam trackbacks / pingbacks so he did not like the 1.02 change. In response, Andy created 1.04 which allows each blogger to either block or allow all trackbacks and pingbacks. Dragonblogger suggests using another plugin to filter those if you have a problem with pingback or trackback spam.

Thanks also to all of our other collaborators who assisted in testing and these bloggers who are using this plugin:

{ 427 comments… read them below or add one }

Rob
Twitter:
May 23, 2013 at 4:46 am

I have also used GASP for quite some time now and have been thrilled with the results. However, recently I am now getting increased spam into my inbox daily. Hope this can be fixed, as I do appreciate the work you have done to rid spammers!
Rob would love you to read ..Air Travel Health TipsMy Profile

Reply

Eric Bobrow who writes about ArchiCAD training tutorials
Twitter:
May 18, 2013 at 8:18 am

I have been using GASP for a long time, and it’s worked really well. However, recently I have been seeing spam comments get through the plugin. They are pretty clever, actually quoting whole sentences or paragaphs from my blog, so the words are strangely familiar (I wrote them). They do not have links in the comment itself, only in the attribute for the comment author.
I tried changing the checkbox name in the GASP admin area, but that didn’t help. Has anyone else started to see these new types of spam comments showing up? I am concerned that what is a small problem now (perhaps one or two a day) will get much worse over the coming months. I have been relying on GASP, and don’t even know what other options there are for blocking this stuff!
Eric Bobrow
Eric Bobrow would love you to read ..Wow! My ArchiCAD Tutorials have over 800,000 Views!My Profile

Reply

GrowMap
Twitter:
May 20, 2013 at 8:19 am

Hi Eric,

I’m seeing the same issue and wonder if these aren’t trackbacks that look like comments? Do you have your WP set to allow trackbacks? Are you using GASP built into CommentLuv Premium or the free version?

I’ll tweet your comment to Andy @CommentLuv in case he has a solution already.
GrowMap would love you to read ..For Bloggers Who Hate Comment SpamMy Profile

Reply

Eric Bobrow who writes about architect marketing strategies
Twitter:
May 20, 2013 at 9:20 am

They are definitely comments, not trackbacks. What is rather strange is that the text for the comment is always my own words, but (I think) not always from the same page on the site.
I am using the free version of GASP, and have it set to block trackbacks (I recently turned this feature on, since trackbacks are not important for my posts at this point).
I would consider paying for CommentLuv if it resolved this issue. Is CommentLuv a single price for use on multiple domains?
Eric Bobrow would love you to read ..Wow! My ArchiCAD Tutorials have over 800,000 Views!My Profile

Reply

GrowMap
Twitter:
May 20, 2013 at 3:34 pm

Hi Eric,

I’ve seen many different programs that pull text from either the post itself, another post on the same site, or a post or comment on a different site about the same topic. Any comment that includes the title is immediately suspect as are others that seem “vaguely familiar”.

There are more settings in the CommentLuv Premium (CLP) version of GASP than the free version. The main difference for me seems to be that if you use CLP it puts these into the spam area and if you use the free version it doesn’t.

I have links to CommentLuv Premium reviews and wrote up the Features of CommentLuv Premium here.

Without GASP this blog was getting flooded with over 1000 comments a day. When I got the first free version that dropped to about 40 with almost all of them real comments. I don’t even want to imagine what that number would be now.

Andy has done a good job of staying ahead of the spammers who are intent on hitting sites like this one. Some days I do have some of the comments like the ones you mention, but most days I don’t have any. I do delete a lot of manually left spam comments. GASP can’t do anything about those.

Some run other plugins to police those, but I haven’t found it necessary. Any system that lets anyone decide what spam is will end up banning most people who leave comments because there is no consensus on what spam is. I choose to approve comments others would delete.

Even though I rarely comment on blogs whose owners I don’t already know any more (partly because I know so many bloggers, and partly because I am too busy to go out commenting), Akismet keeps blacklisting me. Maybe major sites I occasionally comment on click spam because they don’t like what I write. Who knows?

There are three levels of CommentLuv Premium license: single site, multi-site and unlimited developer license. They are currently $67, $87, and $97 (but that could change as Andy has indicated he will raise the price. He sometimes runs promotions, but usually only once a year.) You can read about it at those other links or Buy CommentLuv Premium here.

There are many other reasons I use it in the blogs I control including to encourage social sharing and because it eliminates multiple other plugins I used to need. It replaces 7-8 other functions serious bloggers use such as the Twitter field, sharing, reply-me, etc. I see he also indicates that he has added human anti-spam heuristics, so that may be why I get fewer manually left spam in this blog than I do in blogs I edit and contribute on that only have the free version of GASP.

I won’t moderate comments on any blog I work with unless they install GASP because my readers know I will dig out their comments and I don’t have hours a day to waste deleting all that junk Akismet permits.
GrowMap would love you to read ..Bloggers: Promote Your Blogs HereMy Profile

Reply

Kian May 2, 2013 at 6:47 pm

Thank You for the best spam blocker GASP. I use it for all my blog but as your important notice “suddenly get an influx of spam and trackback spam”, yes its happen to almost my blogs. Now I found the answer. Thanks again. Great plugin!
Kian would love you to read ..Ultrabook TerbaruMy Profile

Reply

Belinda April 29, 2013 at 7:18 pm

this is great I have been looking everywhere for a good anti spamming plugin, will try these out, thanks for the article
Belinda would love you to read ..Hide My Ass voted best bittorrent VPN or proxyMy Profile

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge
This blog uses premium CommentLuv which allows you to put your keywords with your name if you have had 1 approved comments. Use your real name and then @ your keywords (maximum of 5) WARNING: Comments that contain ONLY keywords are likely to be deleted. Please use a name followed by @ your keywords.

{ 191 trackbacks }